| Jahr | Name | Pos | Schule | Nom. |
|---|
| 1981 | Neal Broten | F | University of Minnesota | 1 |
| Steve Ulseth | F | University of Minnesota | 1 |
| Sandy Beadle | F | Northeastern University | 1 |
| Steve Bozek | F | Northern Michigan University | 1 |
| Steve Carroll | G | Minnesota State University, Mankato | 1 |
| Mark Hentges | F | University of St. Thomas | 1 |
| Tom Lawler | F | Merrimack College | 1 |
| Bill Provencher | G | Bowdoin College | 1 |
| Ed Small | D | Clarkson University | 1 |
| Rick Strack | G | Plattsburgh State University | 1 |
| 1982 | George McPhee | F | Bowling Green State University | 1 |
| Ron Scott | G | Michigan State University | 1 |
| Ed Beers | F | University of Denver | 1 |
| Steve Cruickshank | F | Clarkson University | 1 |
| Bryan Erickson | F | University of Minnesota | 1 |
| Brian Hills | F | Bowling Green State University | 1 |
| Paul Lohnes | D | University of Massachusetts Lowell | 1 |
| Kirk McCaskill | F | University of Vermont | 1 |
| John Newberry | F | University of Wisconsin–Madison | 1 |
| Dave Poulin | F | University of Notre Dame | 1 |
| 1983 | Mark Fusco | D | Harvard University | 1 |
| Randy Velischek | D | Providence College | 1 |
| Scott Bjugstad | F | University of Minnesota | 1 |
| Bob Brooke | D | Yale University | 1 |
| Mike Carr | F | University of Massachusetts Lowell | 1 |
| Bryan Erickson | F | University of Minnesota | 2 |
| Brian Hills | F | Bowling Green State University | 2 |
| Kurt Kleinendorst | F | Providence College | 1 |
| James Patrick | D | University of North Dakota | 1 |
| Ron Scott | G | Michigan State University | 2 |
| 1984 | Tom Kurvers | D | University of Minnesota Duluth | 1 |
| Cleon Daskalakis | G | Boston University | 1 |
| Jon Casey | G | University of North Dakota | 1 |
| Paul Donato | F | Babson College | 1 |
| Dan Dorion | F | Western Michigan University | 1 |
| Gaetano Orlando | F | Providence College | 1 |
| Joel Otto | F | Bemidji State University | 1 |
| Paul Pooley | F | Ohio State University | 1 |
| Jean Roy | D | Bowdoin College | 1 |
| Steve Smith | F | Colgate University | 1 |
| 1985 | Bill Watson | F | University of Minnesota Duluth | 1 |
| Scott Fusco | F | Harvard University | 1 |
| Tim Army | F | Providence College | 1 |
| Dave Fretz | D | Clarkson University | 1 |
| Hubie McDonough | F | Saint Anselm College | 1 |
| Pat Micheletti | F | University of Minnesota | 1 |
| Kelly Miller | F | Michigan State University | 1 |
| Adam Oates | F | Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute | 1 |
| Craig Simpson | F | Michigan State University | 1 |
| Ray Staszak | F | University of Illinois–Chicago | 1 |
| 1986 | Scott Fusco | F | Harvard University | 2 |
| Dan Dorion | F | Western Michigan University | 2 |
| Mike Donnelly | F | Michigan State University | 1 |
| Gary Emmons | F | Northern Michigan University | 1 |
| Dallas Gaume | F | University of Denver | 1 |
| Scott Harlow | F | Boston College | 1 |
| Brett Hull | F | University of Minnesota Duluth | 1 |
| Norm Maciver | D | University of Minnesota Duluth | 1 |
| Scott Sandelin | D | University of North Dakota | 1 |
| Chris Terreri | G | Providence College | 1 |
| 1987 | Tony Hrkac | F | University of North Dakota | 1 |
| Wayne Gagné | D | Western Michigan University | 1 |
| John Cullen | F | Boston University | 1 |
| Gary Emmons | F | Northern Michigan University | 2 |
| Tony Granato | F | University of Wisconsin–Madison | 1 |
| Craig Janney | F | Boston College | 1 |
| Brian Leetch | D | Boston College | 1 |
| Lane MacDonald | F | Harvard University | 1 |
| Joe Nieuwendyk | F | Cornell University | 1 |
| Tom Sasso | F | Babson College | 1 |
| 1988 | Robb Stauber | G | University of Minnesota | 1 |
| Mark Vermette | F | Lake Superior State University | 1 |
| Phil Berger | F | Northern Michigan University | 1 |
| Réjean Boivin | F | Colgate University | 1 |
| Dave Capuano | F | University of Maine | 1 |
| Nelson Emerson | F | Bowling Green State University | 1 |
| Mike Golden | F | University of Maine | 1 |
| Steve Johnson | F | University of North Dakota | 1 |
| Peter Lappin | F | St. Lawrence University | 1 |
| Paul Ranheim | F | University of Wisconsin–Madison | 1 |
| 1989 | Lane MacDonald | F | Harvard University | 2 |
| Robb Stauber | G | University of Minnesota | 2 |
| Allen Bourbeau | F | Harvard University | 1 |
| Greg Brown | D | Boston College | 1 |
| Dave Capuano | F | University of Maine | 2 |
| Nelson Emerson | F | Bowling Green State University | 2 |
| Bruce Hoffort | G | Lake Superior State University | 1 |
| Kip Miller | F | Michigan State University | 1 |
| Bobby Reynolds | F | Michigan State University | 1 |
| Tim Sweeney | F | Boston College | 1 |
| 1990 | Kip Miller | F | Michigan State University | 2 |
| Greg Brown | D | Boston College | 2 |
| Rick Bennett | F | Providence College | 1 |
| Rob Blake | D | Bowling Green State University | 1 |
| Nelson Emerson | F | Bowling Green State University | 3 |
| David Emma | F | Boston College | 1 |
| Dave Gagnon | G | Colgate University | 1 |
| Joé Juneau | F | Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute | 1 |
| Russ Parent | D | University of North Dakota | 1 |
| Dave Shields | F | University of Denver | 1 |
| 1991 | David Emma | F | Boston College | 2 |
| Brad Werenka | D | Northern Michigan University | 1 |
| Scott Beattie | F | Northern Michigan University | 1 |
| Peter Ciavaglia | F | Harvard University | 1 |
| Jim Dowd | F | Lake Superior State University | 1 |
| Denny Felsner | F | University of Michigan | 1 |
| Greg Johnson | F | University of North Dakota | 1 |
| Joé Juneau | F | Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute | 2 |
| Shawn McEachern | F | Boston University | 1 |
| Jean-Yves Roy | F | University of Maine | 1 |
| 1992 | Scott Pellerin | F | University of Maine | 1 |
| Daniel Laperrière | D | St. Lawrence University | 1 |
| Scott Beattie | F | Northern Michigan University | 2 |
| Duane Derksen | G | University of Wisconsin–Madison | 1 |
| Denny Felsner | F | University of Michigan | 2 |
| Rob Gaudreau | D | Providence College | 1 |
| Greg Johnson | F | University of North Dakota | 2 |
| Darrin Madeley | G | Lake Superior State University | 1 |
| Larry Olimb | F | University of Minnesota | 1 |
| Jean-Yves Roy | F | University of Maine | 2 |
| 1993 | Paul Kariya | F | University of Maine | 1 |
| Greg Johnson | F | University of North Dakota | 3 |
| Ted Drury | F | Harvard University | 1 |
| Mark Kaufmann | F | Yale University | 1 |
| Jim Montgomery | F | University of Maine | 1 |
| Derek Plante | F | University of Minnesota Duluth | 1 |
| Brian Rolston | F | Lake Superior State University | 1 |
| David Sacco | F | Boston University | 1 |
| Brian Savage | F | Miami University | 1 |
| Bryan Smolinski | F | Michigan State University | 1 |
| 1994 | Chris Marinucci | F | University of Minnesota Duluth | 1 |
| Craig Conroy | F | Clarkson University | 1 |
| Dean Fedorchuk | F | University of Alaska Fairbanks | 1 |
| Neil Little | G | Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute | 1 |
| Sean McCann | D | Harvard University | 1 |
| David Oliver | F | University of Michigan | 1 |
| Jamie Ram | G | Michigan Tech | 1 |
| Dwayne Roloson | G | University of Massachusetts Lowell | 1 |
| Steve Shields | G | University of Michigan | 1 |
| Brian Wiseman | F | University of Michigan | 1 |
| 1995 | Brian Holzinger | F | Bowling Green State University | 1 |
| Chris Imes | D | University of Maine | 1 |
| Brian Bonin | F | University of Minnesota | 1 |
| Greg Bullock | F | University of Massachusetts Lowell | 1 |
| Anson Carter | F | Michigan State University | 1 |
| Mike Grier | F | Boston University | 1 |
| Jay McNeill | F | Colorado College | 1 |
| Brendan Morrison | F | University of Michigan | 1 |
| Brian Mueller | D | Clarkson University | 1 |
| Martin St. Louis | F | University of Vermont | 1 |
| 1996 | Brian Bonin | F | University of Minnesota | 2 |
| Jay Pandolfo | F | Boston University | 1 |
| Keith Aldridge | D | Lake Superior State University | 1 |
| Mike Crowley | D | University of Minnesota | 1 |
| Chris Drury | F | Boston University | 1 |
| Peter Geronazzo | F | Colorado College | 1 |
| Brendan Morrison | F | University of Michigan | 2 |
| Burke Murphy | F | St. Lawrence University | 1 |
| Éric Perrin | F | University of Vermont | 1 |
| Martin St. Louis | F | University of Vermont | 2 |
| 1997 | Brendan Morrison | F | University of Michigan | 3 |
| Chris Drury | F | Boston University | 2 |
| Jason Blake | F | University of North Dakota | 1 |
| Mike Crowley | D | University of Minnesota | 2 |
| Mike Harder | F | Colgate University | 1 |
| John Madden | F | University of Michigan | 1 |
| Randy Robitaille | F | Miami University | 1 |
| Martin St. Louis | F | University of Vermont | 3 |
| Brian Swanson | F | Colorado College | 1 |
| Todd White | F | Clarkson University | 1 |
| 1998 | Chris Drury | F | Boston University | 3 |
| Chad Alban | G | Michigan State University | 1 |
| Dan Boyle | D | Miami University | 1 |
| Ray Giroux | D | Yale University | 1 |
| Eric Healey | F | Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute | 1 |
| Jason Krog | F | University of New Hampshire | 1 |
| Mark Mowers | F | University of New Hampshire | 1 |
| Bill Muckalt | F | University of Michigan | 1 |
| Curtis Murphy | D | University of North Dakota | 1 |
| Mike York | F | Michigan State University | 1 |
| 1999 | Jason Krog | F | University of New Hampshire | 2 |
| Mike York | F | Michigan State University | 2 |
| Jason Blake | F | University of North Dakota | 2 |
| Hugo Boisvert | F | Ohio State University | 1 |
| Brian Gionta | F | Boston College | 1 |
| Jeff Hamilton | F | Yale University | 1 |
| Eric Heffler | G | St. Lawrence University | 1 |
| Steve Kariya | F | University of Maine | 1 |
| Michel Larocque | G | Boston University | 1 |
| Brian Swanson | F | Colorado College | 2 |
| 2000 | Mike Mottau | D | Boston College | 1 |
| Steve Reinprecht | F | University of Wisconsin–Madison | 1 |
| Mike Comrie | F | University of Michigan | 1 |
| Ty Conklin | G | University of New Hampshire | 1 |
| Jeff Farkas | F | Boston College | 1 |
| Brian Gionta | F | Boston College | 2 |
| Shawn Horcoff | F | Michigan State University | 1 |
| Joel Laing | G | Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute | 1 |
| Andy McDonald | F | Colgate University | 1 |
| Jeff Panzer | F | University of North Dakota | 1 |
| 2001 | Ryan Miller | G | Michigan State University | 1 |
| Brian Gionta | F | Boston College | 3 |
| Jeff Panzer | F | University of North Dakota | 2 |
| Erik Anderson | F | St. Lawrence University | 1 |
| Ty Conklin | G | University of New Hampshire | 2 |
| Jeff Hamilton | F | Yale University | 2 |
| Dany Heatley | F | University of Wisconsin–Madison | 1 |
| Andy Hilbert | F | University of Michigan | 1 |
| Kent Huskins | D | Clarkson University | 1 |
| Jordan Leopold | D | University of Minnesota | 1 |
| 2002 | Jordan Leopold | D | University of Minnesota | 2 |
| Mark Hartigan | F | St. Cloud State University | 1 |
| Darren Haydar | F | University of New Hampshire | 1 |
| Ryan Carter | F | Iona College | 1 |
| Marc Cavosie | F | Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute | 1 |
| Rob Collins | F | Ferris State University | 1 |
| Wade Dubielewicz | G | University of Denver | 1 |
| Jim Fahey | D | Northeastern University | 1 |
| Ryan Miller | G | Michigan State University | 2 |
| Douglas Murray | D | Cornell University | 1 |
| 2003 | Peter Sejna | F | Colorado College | 1 |
| Chris Kunitz | F | Ferris State University | 1 |
| David LeNeveu | G | Cornell University | 1 |
| Ben Eaves | F | Boston College | 1 |
| Christopher Higgins | F | Yale University | 1 |
| John-Michael Liles | D | Michigan State University | 1 |
| Zach Parise | F | University of North Dakota | 1 |
| Tom Preissing | F | Colorado College | 1 |
| Joe Tallari | F | Niagara University | 1 |
| R. J. Umberger | F | Ohio State University | 1 |
| 2004 | Junior Lessard | F | University of Minnesota Duluth | 1 |
| Yann Danis | G | Brown University | 1 |
| Zach Parise | F | University of North Dakota | 2 |
| Keith Ballard | D | University of Minnesota | 1 |
| Brandon Bochenski | F | University of North Dakota | 1 |
| Derek Edwardson | F | Miami University | 1 |
| Thomas Pöck | D | University of Massachusetts | 1 |
| Steve Saviano | F | University of New Hampshire | 1 |
| Jim Slater | F | Michigan State University | 1 |
| Tony Voce | F | Boston College | 1 |
| 2005 | Marty Sertich | F | Colorado College | 1 |
| David McKee | G | Cornell University | 1 |
| Brett Sterling | F | Colorado College | 1 |
| Reid Cashman | D | Quinnipiac University | 1 |
| Patrick Eaves | F | Boston College | 1 |
| Dov Grumet-Morris | G | Harvard University | 1 |
| T. J. Hensick | F | University of Michigan | 1 |
| Colin Murphy | F | Michigan Tech | 1 |
| Jordan Sigalet | G | Bowling Green State University | 1 |
| Tuomas Tarkki | G | Northern Michigan University | 1 |
| 2006 | Matthew Carle | D | University of Denver | 1 |
| Chris Collins | F | Boston College | 1 |
| Brian Elliott | G | University of Wisconsin–Madison | 1 |
| Andy Greene | D | Miami University | 1 |
| Greg Moore | F | University of Maine | 1 |
| Scott Parse | F | University of Nebraska Omaha | 1 |
| Ryan Potulny | F | University of Minnesota | 1 |
| Marty Sertich | F | Colorado College | 2 |
| Brett Sterling | F | Colorado College | 2 |
| T. J. Trevelyan | F | St. Lawrence University | 1 |
| 2007 | Ryan Duncan | F | University of North Dakota | 1 |
| David Brown | G | University of Notre Dame | 1 |
| Eric Ehn | F | United States Air Force Academy | 1 |
| Drew Bagnall | D | St. Lawrence University | 1 |
| John Curry | G | Boston University | 1 |
| Nathan Davis | F | Miami University | 1 |
| Bobby Goepfert | G | St. Cloud State University | 1 |
| T. J. Hensick | F | University of Michigan | 2 |
| David Jones | F | Dartmouth College | 1 |
| Scott Parse | F | University of Nebraska Omaha | 2 |
| 2008 | Kevin Porter | F | University of Michigan | 1 |
| Nathan Gerbe | F | Boston College | 1 |
| Ryan Jones | F | Miami University | 1 |
| Lee Jubinville | F | Princeton University | 1 |
| Simon Lambert | F | Rochester Institute of Technology | 1 |
| Jean-Philippe Lamoureux | G | University of North Dakota | 1 |
| Ryan Lasch | F | St. Cloud State University | 1 |
| Jeff Lerg | G | Michigan State University | 1 |
| T. J. Oshie | F | University of North Dakota | 1 |
| Kevin Regan | G | University of New Hampshire | 1 |
| 2009 | Matt Gilroy | D | Boston University | 1 |
| Brad Thiessen | G | Northeastern University | 1 |
| Colin Wilson | F | Boston University | 1 |
| Louie Caporusso | F | University of Michigan | 1 |
| Chad Johnson | G | University of Alaska Fairbanks | 1 |
| Zane Kalemba | G | Princeton University | 1 |
| Jacques Lamoureux | F | United States Air Force Academy | 1 |
| Jamie McBain | D | University of Wisconsin–Madison | 1 |
| David McIntyre | F | Colgate University | 1 |
| Viktor Stålberg | F | University of Vermont | 1 |
| 2010 | Blake Geoffrion | F | University of Wisconsin–Madison | 1 |
| Bobby Butler | F | University of New Hampshire | 1 |
| Gustav Nyquist | F | University of Maine | 1 |
| Marc Cheverie | G | University of Denver | 1 |
| Mark Olver | F | Northern Michigan University | 1 |
| Chase Polacek | F | Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute | 1 |
| Rhett Rakhshani | F | University of Denver | 1 |
| Cody Reichard | G | Miami University | 1 |
| Ben Scrivens | G | Cornell University | 1 |
| Brendan Smith | D | University of Wisconsin–Madison | 1 |
| 2011 | Andy Miele | F | Miami University | 1 |
| Cam Atkinson | F | Boston College | 1 |
| Matt Frattin | F | University of North Dakota | 1 |
| Carter Camper | F | Miami University | 1 |
| Jack Connolly | F | University of Minnesota Duluth | 1 |
| Gustav Nyquist | F | University of Maine | 2 |
| Chase Polacek | F | Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute | 2 |
| Justin Schultz | D | University of Wisconsin–Madison | 1 |
| Paul Thompson | F | University of New Hampshire | 1 |
| Paul Zanette | F | Niagara University | 1 |
| 2012 | Jack Connolly | F | University of Minnesota Duluth | 2 |
| Spencer Abbott | F | University of Maine | 1 |
| Austin Smith | F | Colgate University | 1 |
| Brian Dumoulin | D | Boston College | 1 |
| Troy Grosenick | G | Union College | 1 |
| Shawn Hunwick | G | University of Michigan | 1 |
| Tim Kirby | D | United States Air Force Academy | 1 |
| Torey Krug | D | Michigan State University | 1 |
| Justin Schultz | D | University of Wisconsin–Madison | 2 |
| Reilly Smith | F | Miami University | 1 |
| 2013 | Drew LeBlanc | F | St. Cloud State University | 1 |
| Johnny Gaudreau | F | Boston College | 1 |
| Eric Hartzell | G | Quinnipiac University | 1 |
| Greg Carey | F | St. Lawrence University | 1 |
| Carsen Chubak | G | Niagara University | 1 |
| Austin Czarnik | F | Miami University | 1 |
| Kyle Flanagan | F | St. Lawrence University | 1 |
| Corban Knight | F | University of North Dakota | 1 |
| Danny Kristo | F | University of North Dakota | 1 |
| Ryan Walters | F | University of Nebraska Omaha | 1 |
| 2014 | Johnny Gaudreau | F | Boston College | 2 |
| Greg Carey | F | St. Lawrence University | 2 |
| Nic Dowd | F | St. Cloud State University | 1 |
| Josh Archibald | F | University of Nebraska Omaha | 1 |
| Ryan Dzingel | F | Ohio State University | 1 |
| Shayne Gostisbehere | D | Union College | 1 |
| Kevin Hayes | F | Boston College | 1 |
| C. J. Motte | G | Ferris State University | 1 |
| Joel Rumpel | G | University of Wisconsin–Madison | 1 |
| Adam Wilcox | G | University of Minnesota | 1 |
| 2015 | Jack Eichel | F | Boston University | 1 |
| Zane McIntyre | G | University of North Dakota | 1 |
| Jimmy Vesey | F | Harvard University | 1 |
| Daniel Ciampini | F | Union College | 1 |
| Matt Garbowsky | F | Rochester Institute of Technology | 1 |
| Zach Hyman | F | University of Michigan | 1 |
| Tanner Kero | F | Michigan Tech | 1 |
| Joey LaLeggia | D | University of Denver | 1 |
| Mike Reilly | D | University of Minnesota | 1 |
| Cody Wydo | F | Robert Morris University | 1 |
| 2016 | Jimmy Vesey | F | Harvard University | 2 |
| Kyle Connor | F | University of Michigan | 1 |
| Thatcher Demko | G | Boston College | 1 |
| J. T. Compher | F | University of Michigan | 1 |
| Zac Lynch | F | Robert Morris University | 1 |
| Alex Lyon | G | Yale University | 1 |
| Tyler Motte | F | University of Michigan | 1 |
| Alex Petan | F | Michigan Tech | 1 |
| Andrew Poturalski | F | University of New Hampshire | 1 |
| Ethan Prow | D | St. Cloud State University | 1 |
| 2017 | Will Butcher | D | University of Denver | 1 |
| Zach Aston-Reese | F | Northeastern University | 1 |
| Mike Vecchione | F | Union College | 1 |
| Michael Bitzer | G | Bemidji State University | 1 |
| Anders Bjork | F | University of Notre Dame | 1 |
| Spencer Foo | F | Union College | 1 |
| Tyler Kelleher | F | University of New Hampshire | 1 |
| Alexander Kerfoot | F | Harvard University | 1 |
| Tyler Sheehy | F | University of Minnesota | 1 |
| Charles Williams | G | Canisius College | 1 |
| 2018 | Adam Gaudette | F | Northeastern University | 1 |
| Henrik Borgström | F | University of Denver | 1 |
| Ryan Donato | F | Harvard University | 1 |
| Matthew Galajda | G | Cornell University | 1 |
| Dylan McLaughlin | F | Canisius College | 1 |
| Cale Morris | G | University of Notre Dame | 1 |
| Colton Point | G | Colgate University | 1 |
| Jimmy Schuldt | D | St. Cloud State University | 1 |
| Dylan Sikura | F | Northeastern University | 1 |
| C. J. Suess | F | Minnesota State University, Mankato | 1 |
| 2019 | Cale Makar | D | University of Massachusetts Amherst | 1 |
| Adam Fox | D | Harvard University | 1 |
| Jimmy Schuldt | D | St. Cloud State University | 2 |
| Joe Duszak | D | Mercyhurst University | 1 |
| Taro Hirose | F | Michigan State University | 1 |
| Quinn Hughes | D | University of Michigan | 1 |
| Mason Jobst | F | Ohio State University | 1 |
| Patrick Newell | F | St. Cloud State University | 1 |
| Chase Priskie | D | Quinnipiac University | 1 |
| Nico Sturm | F | Clarkson University | 1 |
| 2020 | Scott Perunovich | D | University of Minnesota Duluth | 1 |
| Jordan Kawaguchi | F | University of North Dakota | 1 |
| Jeremy Swayman | G | University of Maine | 1 |
| Morgan Barron | F | Cornell University | 1 |
| Jason Cotton | F | Sacred Heart University | 1 |
| Jack Dugan | F | Providence College | 1 |
| David Farrance | D | Boston University | 1 |
| John Leonard | F | University of Massachusetts Amherst | 1 |
| Dryden McKay | G | Minnesota State University, Mankato | 1 |
| Marc Michaelis | F | Minnesota State University, Mankato | 1 |
| 2021 | Cole Caufield | F | University of Wisconsin–Madison | 1 |
| Dryden McKay | G | Minnesota State University, Mankato | 2 |
| Shane Pinto | F | University of North Dakota | 1 |
| Matthew Boldy | F | Boston College | 1 |
| David Farrance | D | Boston University | 2 |
| Dylan Holloway | F | University of Wisconsin–Madison | 1 |
| Spencer Knight | G | Boston College | 1 |
| Jack LaFontaine | G | University of Minnesota | 1 |
| Keith Petruzzelli | G | Quinnipiac University | 1 |
| Odeen Tufto | F | Quinnipiac University | 1 |
| 2022 | Dryden McKay | G | Minnesota State University, Mankato | 3 |
| Bobby Brink | F | University of Denver | 1 |
| Ben Meyers | F | University of Minnesota | 1 |
| Matty Beniers | F | University of Michigan | 1 |
| Brian Halonen | F | Michigan Technological University | 1 |
| Luke Hughes | D | University of Michigan | 1 |
| Devon Levi | G | Northeastern University | 1 |
| Yaniv Perets | G | Quinnipiac University | 1 |
| Nathan Smith | F | Minnesota State University, Mankato | 1 |
| Bobby Trivigno | F | University of Massachusetts Amherst | 1 |
| 2023 | Adam Fantilli | F | University of Michigan | 1 |
| Logan Cooley | F | University of Minnesota | 1 |
| Matthew Knies | F | University of Minnesota | 1 |
| Sean Farrell | F | Harvard University | 1 |
| Collin Graf | F | Quinnipiac University | 1 |
| Lane Hutson | D | Boston University | 1 |
| Devon Levi | G | Northeastern University | 2 |
| Yaniv Perets | G | Quinnipiac University | 2 |
| Blake Pietila | G | Michigan Technological University | 1 |
| Jason Polin | F | Western Michigan University | 1 |
| 2024 | Macklin Celebrini | F | Boston University | 1 |
| Jackson Blake | F | University of North Dakota | 1 |
| Cutter Gauthier | F | Boston College | 1 |
| Jack Devine | F | University of Denver | 1 |
| Collin Graf | F | Quinnipiac University | 2 |
| Lane Hutson | D | Boston University | 2 |
| Kyle McClellan | G | University of Wisconsin–Madison | 1 |
| Liam McLinskey | F | College of the Holy Cross | 1 |
| Sam Morton | F | Minnesota State University, Mankato | 1 |
| Will Smith | C | Boston College | 1 |
| 2025 | Isaac Howard | F | Michigan State University | 1 |
| Zeev Buium | D | University of Denver | 1 |
| Ryan Leonard | F | Boston College | 1 |
| Jack Devine | F | University of Denver | 2 |
| Aiden Fink | F | Pennsylvania State University | 1 |
| Mac Gadowsky | D | United States Military Academy | 1 |
| Ayrton Martino | F | Clarkson University | 1 |
| Liam McLinskey | F | College of the Holy Cross | 2 |
| Jimmy Snuggerud | F | University of Minnesota | 1 |
| Alex Tracy | C | Minnesota State University, Mankato | 1 |